So I am a little obsessed with my feet and their comfort. I already tried some water shoes to keep my feet warm while on the water. They did well and added some arch support but they were a little bulky for a barefoot sport and held water in the shoe.
So, I tried some neoprene with fleece lining socks. They felt like I was wearing socks and the traction on the board was good. They are not as warm as a water shoe but they provide a better feel for the board.